Pre-Release Sales Forecast & Investment Analysis: Frostpunk 2 - Fractured Utopias

Executive Summary

Investment Thesis: "Fractured Utopias" (Release: Dec 8, 2025) faces a critically adverse launch environment. With Frostpunk 2 currently averaging a daily peak of only ~500 Concurrent Users (CCU), the live ecosystem is effectively dormant. Furthermore, the DLC's position at #2400 on the Global Wishlist Chart (T-3 days to launch) indicates a severe lack of fresh demand. Momentum Verdict: Negative / Distressed. The extremely low player retention suggests the "Deluxe Edition" liability (players who pre-paid in 2024) comprises nearly the entire active audience. New liquidity generation will be negligible. Investment Rating: Underperform. This release is unlikely to act as a catalyst for stock recovery. Revenue impact will be primarily accounting-based (deferred revenue recognition) rather than new cash flow.

---

Trend & Momentum Analysis

• Active Player Baseline (Critical): The Base Game has deteriorated to ~500 Peak CCU. For a major strategy sequel 15 months post-launch, this is a "Comatose" state. It implies that organic word-of-mouth is non-existent; the DLC must rely entirely on external marketing to reactivate lapsed users.
• Wishlist Rank Trajectory: Currently #2400 (Global).
  • Analysis: This is significantly below the benchmark for a AA/AAA expansion, which typically polls in the Top 200–500 prior to launch.
  • Implication: The "Paid" market interest is weak. Most interested parties likely already own the Deluxe Edition (and thus do not wishlist the DLC), leaving a very small addressable market of Standard Edition owners looking to upgrade.
• Hype Freshness: Stale. The low Wishlist Rank combined with low CCU indicates that the "Long Tail" has been severed.

---

Market & Sentiment Analysis

• USP Critical Assessment: While the expansion adds "Utopia Builder" depth, the market signals suggest players have moved on to competitors (Civilization VII, Anno). The hook is insufficient to trigger a mass reinstall event.
• The "Deluxe" Cannibalization: We estimate 40-50% of the original launch sales were Deluxe Editions. These users will download the DLC but generate $0.00 in new sales. Because these users are the "core" fans, their activity will mask the lack of new purchases on the "Top Sellers" charts.
• Pricing Strategy: Expected ASP ~$14.00 (Blended). However, given the low Wishlist Rank, we anticipate 11 bit studios may be forced to bundle this content aggressively or discount the Base Game to -50% to drive attachment.

---

Benchmark Comparison

Benchmark: Frostpunk: The Last Autumn (FP1) vs. Frostpunk 2: Fractured Utopias

• FP1 Performance: The Last Autumn released when FP1 still had 3k-4k daily CCU, propelling it to 30k+ CCU.
• FP2 Performance: Starting from 500 CCU makes a similar multiplier mathematically impossible without a viral event.
• Recovery Target: To be considered a success, the DLC needs to boost CCU by 10x (to 5,000+). Current momentum suggests a 3x-5x lift is more realistic (1,500 - 2,500 CCU).

---

Sales & CCU Forecast (12-Month) - DLC Specific

Key Assumptions:

1. High Friction: Reactivating players who haven't touched the game in 6+ months is historically difficult.
2. Low "New" Demand: Rank #2400 implies <15,000 "fresh" highly interested buyers.
3. Revenue: Calculations are for New Cash Flow Only (excluding deferred Deluxe revenue).

Pessimistic Scenario

• Narrative: The launch is a non-event. Only Deluxe owners play. Standard owners ignore it due to price/apathy.
• Paid Attach Rate: <3% of Active Standard Owners.
• New Paid Units (12mo): 12,000 units.
• Estimated Gross Revenue: ~$168,000 USD.
• Launch Peak CCU Target: 1,800.

Neutral Scenario (Most Likely)

• Narrative: A moderate spike driven by Deluxe owners returning, prompting some visibility on Steam, converting a small fraction of the wishlist.
• Paid Attach Rate: 8% of Active Standard Owners.
• New Paid Units (12mo): 45,000 units.
• Estimated Gross Revenue: ~$630,000 USD.
• Launch Peak CCU Target: 3,800.

Optimistic Scenario

• Narrative: Positive reviews coupled with a deep "Gold Edition" discount on the base game bring in new players.
• Paid Attach Rate: 15% + New Users.
• New Paid Units (12mo): 110,000 units.
• Estimated Gross Revenue: ~$1,540,000 USD.
• Launch Peak CCU Target: 8,500.

---

Forecast Charts

Estimated New Gross Revenue Curve (Neutral Scenario) (Values in USD)

---

Risk Factors & Catalysts

• Review Bomb Risk: If the returning Deluxe owners feel the 15-month wait wasn't justified by the content volume, "Mixed" reviews will kill the long tail immediately.
• Visibility Cliff: With Rank #2400, the game will likely miss the "Popular New Releases" front-page visibility slot on Steam, relegated to the "New DLC" tab which has 90% less traffic.

---

Investment Takeaways

• Scale Comparison: For 11 bit studios ($11B), a project generating ~$600k in new annual cash flow is negligible.
• Financial Impact: The report confirms that Frostpunk 2 has failed to retain a live-service tail. The company cannot rely on this IP for recurring high-margin revenue in 2026.
• Strategic Context: The low CCU of base game (500) and low Wishlist Rank for expansion (#2400) signal that the IP is "cooling" much faster than Frostpunk 1. Future investment in Frostpunk 3 or further DLC should be scrutinized heavily by shareholders.

Conclusion

The data points (500 CCU, Rank #2400) paint a picture of a "Zombie Launch." The release will satisfy existing obligations (Deluxe owners) but will fail to generate meaningful new capital. We forecast a muted release with no significant impact on the stock price. Verdict: Sell/Avoid.